top of page
  • Writer's pictureThe DigitalBank Vault

#Encrochat Scandal : Can intercepted communications be relied on in criminal cases? No 👎

Can intercepted communications be relied on in criminal cases?

Section 56(1) of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 (IPA 2016) provides that evidence obtained from live monitored communications (for example phone tapping) is deemed unreliable if the interception was conducted in the UK and at least one of the parties to the communication is present in the country. Therefore, to be relied on in a court in England and Wales, the prosecution will need to prove that any EncroChat interception took place in France, an extremely tricky undertaking, especially given that French authorities are refusing to disclose their methodology.

Why did the French court rule that EncroChat evidence can be challenged by the defence?

The case arose from an appeal concerning the judgment of the Nancy Court of Appeal in the matter of Saïd Zaoui, who was arrested in June 2020 and indicted on charges of importing narcotics and possession of weapons and ammunition following the EncroChat hack. Because the investigative technique used by the police came under the category of national security, the defence was not able to assess how the hack was done.

However, French law states that in such cases, the police must produce a ‘certificate of truthfulness’. The court in Nancy ruled that the police did not have to produce the certificate. However, the Court of Cassation stated the lower court erred in this decision and referred the case back to a Metz court to establish if a certificate of truthfulness exists.

Highly reliable sources have indicated that there is no such certificate in existence.

The French decision is likely to strengthen defence solicitors’ arguments against the NCA’s “tenuous basis” for a TEI warrant. It also provides a basis for UK defence solicitors to challenge any convictions, prosecutions, or investigations in which the prosecution seeks to rely on evidence obtained from the EncroChat hack.


Our Cyber Defense Engineers provide clients with the most advanced know how and sophisticated encryption technologies for securing their top secret corporate communications, classified file transfers and sensitive data storage. We invite to to consult with us for Free.  

Start Your Own Business of Encrypted Phones & Laptops with just $ 5K ! Telegram/Signal/ WhatsApp +37257347873  or ENCRYGMA.COM


The Encrygma Yearly Program 

Own your Private Encrypted Communication Network : 



✅ UNLIMITED MOBILE & DESKTOP ENCRYPTION MACHINES: Yearly License plan for unlimited installs of the Encrygma Offline Encryption System , on Android devices and Windows PCs ( you can install it on how many devices you want )

✅ UNLIMITED ENCRYPTED PHONES & ENCRYPTED LAPTOPS :  Yearly License plan for unlimited installs of the Avvo.Club  the online Peer to Peer Ultra Encrypted Communication Network on any iPhone, Android, MacBook and  and Windows PCs 

✅ For Each Client a Private , Unique Offline Encryption System and Private Real Time Communication Network with a dedicated set of encryption algorithms, creating like that a fully privately owned , fully controlled internal, super encrypted communication network.    

✅ Personal, Professional online training of the company's team to quantum safe encryption methodologies and top classified, ultra encrypted communications. 

✅ One year , 24/7 Full Online Technical Support + Private Consulting + Online Covert Communications courses + Ongoing upgrades and maintenance .

Let us know your secrecy needs !

We are here to help you achieve absolute secrecy.


Consult with us today for free on : 

or on Whatsapp/ Telegram/ Signal at 


10 views0 comments


bottom of page